Dominant groups have long used public monuments to project their power and narrative. How do divisive monuments affect where dissenting groups choose to live?
In Barcelona School of Economics Working Paper 1520, “Symbols of Oppression: The Role of Confederate Monuments in the Great Migration”, Francesco Ferlenga provides quasi-experimental and experimental evidence on the effect of divisive monuments on the location choices of dissenting groups, focusing on Confederate monuments erected by Southern whites in the early 20th-century United States and opposed by Black Americans.
Ferlenga shows that the construction of Confederate monuments in the US South reduced Black population shares via out-migration and that, even today, Black Americans are less likely to accept job offers in cities where they see the presence of a Confederate monument.
The Presence of Monuments Substantially Reduced the Black Share of the Population
Ferlenga finds that the construction of a monument changed the migration patterns and reduced the Black share of the population by 5 percentage points (Figure 1 below).
His research confirms the negative and significant effect of Confederate monuments on the Black share of the population.

Notes: Event study results; the event is the first construction date in each county. Controls: lag of population; county and state-by-year fixed effects; clustering at county level. 95% confidence interval.
To distinguish causality from coincidence or the impact of confounding factors, Ferlenga relies on an instrumental variable (IV) strategy that uses the connection to a monument producer and the time of production as his instrument.
Ferlenga proposes two mechanisms to explain this result:
- Direct effect: Confederate monuments may visually increase the salience of racial discrimination
- Indirect effect: Confederate monuments may contribute to a more hostile local environment
His findings align with the direct mechanism, while he finds little support for the indirect effect.
Confederate Monuments Had a Long-term Negative Effect on The Economy
Ferlenga also studies the long-term effects of monument construction on the economy by examining changes in the value of farmland and buildings.
He finds that monument construction induced a reduction in farm values in the counties, after a 10-year lag, when compared to counties with no such monument.
This suggests that the detrimental effect on farmland values caused by the lower population pressure and by the increased scarcity of agricultural labor may have outweighed the southern whites’ preference for a public space reflecting their supremacy.
Confederate Monuments Continue to Influence Migration Preferences
The author conducts an online experiment in which he presents images of five hypothetical cities to each respondent, and he randomizes the presence of Confederate monuments when visually describing each city. He asks respondents about their willingness to relocate for a job offer in these cities and the lowest wage they would be willing to accept (reservation wage).
The results (Figure 2) show that the presence of a Confederate monument significantly reduces Black respondents’ propensity to relocate there and raises their reservation wage. Although he finds a significant effect for Southern whites, the effect size is approximately 50% lower than that for Black respondents.
Figure 2. Decision to accept the job offer or not. Black American respondents only


Notes: Control group saw the depicted city with no monument, treated group saw it with a monument
Ferlenga analyzes the post-experiment comments regarding the meaning of monuments for the respondents. These comments (Figure 3) suggest that the higher effect induced by monuments on Black Americans’ job acceptance rate stems from a different interpretation of these monuments by race: for whites, Confederate monuments are just a remaining legacy of history, for Black Americans they are active signals of racism in the area.
Figure 3. How do you feel when you think about or encounter a Confederate monument?


Notes: Raw distribution of the responses to the main outcomes. “Treated” group saw the monument
Key Research Insights
Ferlenga’s paper shows that divisive monuments in public spaces can influence location decisions for groups with opposing views on such symbols.
- Confederate monuments acted as active signals of racial intimidation
- Black population shares dropped by 5 percentage points following monument construction
- Labor flight caused significant, long-term Southern economic decline

